I have only been playing the mandolin for a short time and so I can only compare this case with my other cases which are for bass guitars. However, it compares well, and considering the price, is a good purchase.
The case is light and but well padded. However careful you are, things take knocks, getting in and out of cars and going through doors, but don't have concerns about my instrument in this case.
It does what you want it to do. My mandolin fits in snugly and feels like it is held firmly. The pocket is smallish but holds the essentials. The carrying handle balances the case well and the shoulder straps, although thin are comfortable enough as mandolins are so light. A purchase that I am pretty pleased with.