AB
Not Just A Novelty
Okay, so leaving aside the soprano trombone vs slide trumpet debate, what you've got here is a cheap 'mini trombone' that is... er... what it is - a cheap soprano trombone. Its small, shiny, makes the right sounds, is light and comes with a decent case.
Until you get into the more specialist trombones, they are about as basic as a brass instrument can get: a bell, a brass tube, the slide section and the mouthpiece. There's still a lot that can go wrong with that but any more basic and you'll be buying a kazoo!
The bell and tubing are all solid but, like any instrument, don't sit on it. The welds are secure throughout, the spit-key does what it should and the slides are smooth. Overall, it's well-crafted. No frills and bows, but if there was anything fancy, you'd have to wonder where they were cutting costs to keep the price down.
The only 'fault' I've found is more about taking care with maintence - the slide lock (stops the slide falling off when not playing) will jam if you don't keep it clean and oil around it. It says more about me than it does the instrument.
The mouthpiece is your basic bog-standard mouthpiece that comes with any new instrument. Not brilliant, but not as god-awful as some other cheap instruments on the market.
In terms of playability, you've got the soprano range, which puts you in the trumpet zone, which when combined with the short slide length makes it a useful tool for introducing kids to the trombone. However, if you're playing one as an adult, you need to make a few adjustments. Just make sure to move the bell section around a few more degrees to help it sit more comfortably and don't hold the slide grip with the whole finger as you would on a standard trombone - you'll be scraping your knuckles on the bell if you do.
This does pretty much what a trombone should, just in a higher range. Yes, it will take time getting used to the short spacing of each position and the tone will be different from a tenor when you're at the lower end of the range but that's why you shouldn't see it as a novelty instrument. Saxophonists will switch between upper and lower range instruments just because the tonality gives them a totally different sound. If you're a trombonist looking at getting something new into your music, this makes for a bargain way to experiment with the range of sound you can achieve.
Until you get into the more specialist trombones, they are about as basic as a brass instrument can get: a bell, a brass tube, the slide section and the mouthpiece. There's still a lot that can go wrong with that but any more basic and you'll be buying a kazoo!
The bell and tubing are all solid but, like any instrument, don't sit on it. The welds are secure throughout, the spit-key does what it should and the slides are smooth. Overall, it's well-crafted. No frills and bows, but if there was anything fancy, you'd have to wonder where they were cutting costs to keep the price down.
The only 'fault' I've found is more about taking care with maintence - the slide lock (stops the slide falling off when not playing) will jam if you don't keep it clean and oil around it. It says more about me than it does the instrument.
The mouthpiece is your basic bog-standard mouthpiece that comes with any new instrument. Not brilliant, but not as god-awful as some other cheap instruments on the market.
In terms of playability, you've got the soprano range, which puts you in the trumpet zone, which when combined with the short slide length makes it a useful tool for introducing kids to the trombone. However, if you're playing one as an adult, you need to make a few adjustments. Just make sure to move the bell section around a few more degrees to help it sit more comfortably and don't hold the slide grip with the whole finger as you would on a standard trombone - you'll be scraping your knuckles on the bell if you do.
This does pretty much what a trombone should, just in a higher range. Yes, it will take time getting used to the short spacing of each position and the tone will be different from a tenor when you're at the lower end of the range but that's why you shouldn't see it as a novelty instrument. Saxophonists will switch between upper and lower range instruments just because the tonality gives them a totally different sound. If you're a trombonist looking at getting something new into your music, this makes for a bargain way to experiment with the range of sound you can achieve.
9
0
Report
A
Poor quality
After just a couple months the plating on the inner slide started to come off, and the slide became harder to move, and making more scratch-noises. I didn't expect this bad quality, and i do not recommend it to others unless Thomann resolve this issue with the slide.
Apart from the slide, the trombone is fun to play, yet a little difficult (this might just be me, as a not that experienced tenor-trombone player). Definitely fun exept for the poor plating!
Edit:
I've contacted Thomann and they have resolved the problem. I give the service at Thomann at least 6 stars!
Apart from the slide, the trombone is fun to play, yet a little difficult (this might just be me, as a not that experienced tenor-trombone player). Definitely fun exept for the poor plating!
Edit:
I've contacted Thomann and they have resolved the problem. I give the service at Thomann at least 6 stars!
9
3
Report
C
Pee-woo-weep
My wife has been desperate for one of these for years and when I saw that the price was perfect for a Christmas present I bought one right away.
It represents great value and the build quality is outstanding in it's price bracket. The fact that it comes with slide grease, a polishing cloth and some natty white gloves serves to underline the attention to detail Thomann gives to its products.
The slide was, initially, a little rough, but I expected that from a brand new tombone and was fine after a good lubing. The mouthpiece (a trumpet one) is also of good quality for the price bracket and fits nicely.
The only downside for me is that the vinyl covering on the (still sturdy) hard case has started to peel after only three months and it has never left the house. This is extremely minor and I think it's pure bad luck and I would've expected a gig bag in this price bracket.
If you fancy a teeny-weeny trombone you could do far, far worse than trying out this wee beauty.
It represents great value and the build quality is outstanding in it's price bracket. The fact that it comes with slide grease, a polishing cloth and some natty white gloves serves to underline the attention to detail Thomann gives to its products.
The slide was, initially, a little rough, but I expected that from a brand new tombone and was fine after a good lubing. The mouthpiece (a trumpet one) is also of good quality for the price bracket and fits nicely.
The only downside for me is that the vinyl covering on the (still sturdy) hard case has started to peel after only three months and it has never left the house. This is extremely minor and I think it's pure bad luck and I would've expected a gig bag in this price bracket.
If you fancy a teeny-weeny trombone you could do far, far worse than trying out this wee beauty.
5
0
Report
A
What do you expect for £90
I think it is a good little trombone. My slide was ok but I took it to a friend who is an instrument technician, he polished the inside of the outer slide using brasso! The result was amazing it now runs like glass! I also had an adaptor made so I could use a Bach 3 for Eb horn , it now sounds more like a trombone but I will have to work on the high notes but goes up to F with no probs!
4
0
Report
A
Fantastic Little Trombone
The Thomann SL5 is a fantastic soprano trombone, ideal for trumpet players and trombonists alike. Positions are more-or-less where you'd expect them to be, and the instrument has a lovely sound.
The tuning bell is a little too short, and therefore it can be difficult to tune the instrument without it ending up a little sharp. But this is common in all soprano trombones at this price point.
The instrument is well made and the slide is slick. The lacquer is more heavy wearing than most instruments at this price, and I haven't had any issues with it rubbing off yet.
The mouthpiece included with the instrument isn't good at all, but it will take any standard trumpet mouthpiece, so find one that suits you. The case had a couple of rough edges, and I have cut my hand several times from sharp rivets on the handle.
This instrument is perfect as an extra little bit of fun for trumpet players or trombonists in jazz ensembles to add that little extra, and is also suitable for a range of more 'modern' trombone quartet repertoire.
Would highly recommend.
The tuning bell is a little too short, and therefore it can be difficult to tune the instrument without it ending up a little sharp. But this is common in all soprano trombones at this price point.
The instrument is well made and the slide is slick. The lacquer is more heavy wearing than most instruments at this price, and I haven't had any issues with it rubbing off yet.
The mouthpiece included with the instrument isn't good at all, but it will take any standard trumpet mouthpiece, so find one that suits you. The case had a couple of rough edges, and I have cut my hand several times from sharp rivets on the handle.
This instrument is perfect as an extra little bit of fun for trumpet players or trombonists in jazz ensembles to add that little extra, and is also suitable for a range of more 'modern' trombone quartet repertoire.
Would highly recommend.
3
0
Report
G
Good Demonstrator
I find this a little difficult to play. It's nothing to do with quality etc. but the resistance is a bit too low for me. I find it easy to miss pitch notes but that can be solved by practice. A good slide lubricant is a must though. I use the same as I use on my tenor trombone slide and that works very well. The quality of the construction is actually very good. This is great to use as a demonstrator for use in schools and due to it's price isn't a problem if it should become damaged.
2
0
Report
s
Tiny little trombone
This trombone is absolutely adorable! It seems rather well made, however the slide is very stiff and makes noise when moved. The slide lock also screeches when it's rotated. If it weren't for the slide and slide lock, then this would be the perfect soprano trombone! 7/10.
0
0
Report
GA
A cool toy, not much more than that
Very easy to play, sounds pretty good, but has no tuning slide and the slide can be rotated even with the instrument fully assembled.
A cool toy but very limited as an instrument.
A cool toy but very limited as an instrument.
0
0
Report
